Broken Pieces: Thoughts on Shawn Marion and "The Insider"
"What got broken here doesn't go back together."
When I first read that Shawn Marion wants to be traded, that quote from Al Pacino's character was one of several from the movie The Insider that immediately came to mind. It doesn't matter now if Shawn or the Suns have a change of heart. The words have been spoken, and it's too late to take them back. There are teammates who won't forget. There are fans who won't forget. And the media will never forget. Ever. Any attempt to keep the Matrix in a Suns uniform at this point would likely carry with it such an enormous distraction that it probably isn't even worth pursuing. In short, what's done is done, and there's no turning back the clock. Time to move on, as Marion says.
"I'm just a commodity to you, aren't I?"
Is it fair to put all the blame on the Suns for failing to realize just how unhappy Shawn had become? I don't think so. But I don't think it's fair to blame Shawn 100% for it either. Let's put this in a "real world" perspective for a moment. Say you've worked for a company for eight years. You were there before any of your co-workers. You have poured your heart and soul into it, hardly ever missing a day, and yet it always seems like your accomplishments are barely mentioned while two of your co-workers get most of the credit. And if that weren't enough to make you feel like Dilbert on a bad day, you have to listen every year to rumors that you're going to be transferred to another division. You know you'll never get promoted, you're not likely to be invited back once your current project is through (unless you take a sizable pay cut), and on top of that, you get to hear your name come up in every bleeping rumor about personnel changes that comes across your boss's desk! Even if you were working for the best company in the world, there would probably come a time when you'd finally decide it's best to go ahead and part ways while you still had at least some control of your destiny.
"You don't get to 'instruct' anything around here!"
The Suns have every reason to feel slighted too, though. They have made Shawn their highest-paid player, and kept him all this time because--whether he realizes it or not--they value what he brings to this team! It is perfectly reasonable for them to expect him to fulfill the contract he signed, even if it means dealing with trades and rumors that are a normal part of life in the NBA. Did the Suns try to send him to Boston so they could obtain Kevin Garnett? Probably. But come on! How many players in the league would not be gladly offered up by their team's GM for a guy like KG? You could probably count them on one hand! And lest we forget, Boston really, really wanted Shawn! Couldn't he somehow manage to feel good about that? Didn't he learn anything from Steve Nash's experience with Dallas?
"I fought for you and I still fight for you!"
We fans have a right to feel jilted as well. In our own way, we have fought for Shawn. We have cheered him on for years. We have defended him to detractors. We have shared his frustration at the repeated trade rumors, and the inexplicable, inexcusable snubbing by those who vote on the All-Defensive team. We have thoroughly enjoyed watching every alley-oop dunk, every steal, every rebound. For some of us, he's even a major part of why we started watching the Suns to begin with. We wanted him to succeed. We wanted him to be happy here. Most of all, we wanted him to share in the joy of getting to win a championship with this team. His trade request is like a slap in the face to every one of us who have invested our time, our energy, and our money to watch him play. We deserved better than this public "laundry-airing" that will hurt his value and lessen our team.
"Is there an echo in here? Your objection's been recorded."
Perhaps the media shares some of the blame as well, and bloggers like me who have jumped on every chance to make a mountain out of a molehill whenever Shawn (or Amare or anyone else for that matter) says something that could be construed as controversial. It's a great way to get a discussion going (or sell a newspaper), but is it possible all that talk about Shawn being disgruntled eventually turned into a self-fulfilling prophecy? After all, it was the media who constantly brought those trade rumors to his attention time and time again, needling him like some mean little kid taunting a caged animal with a stick. And the rest of us just couldn't link to those articles fast enough, pouncing on quotes that may or may not have been taken out of context. Perhaps on some small level, we all helped to create this problem.
"Do you wish you hadn't come forward? Do you wish you hadn't blown the whistle?"
There is a part of me that believes, and even hopes that Shawn will realize a year from now he has made a huge mistake. It is a normal reaction of the jilted to wish regret on the person who did the jilting. But when it comes down to it, I can also appreciate that Shawn has been a loyal employee of the Suns for the past eight years. In all that time, he never allowed his unhappiness to stand between him and his team. Were the Suns to keep him despite his request, I have no doubt he would go out there and leave it all on the floor like he always has. I also believe he means it when he says he loves his teammates, Phoenix, and the fans. There is no way I can wish anything but the best for him, regardless of how angry I am at the moment. Whatever it is he's looking for, I truly hope he finds it. But I certainly won't mind if he has an "off" night whenever he plays the Suns.
0 recs |
35 comments
Comments
nice but...
The trade talks, that part of basketball, someone needs to tell Marion that the phoenix suns aren't his father, and them looking into trades isn't like a father abandoning his son, but more like a
company looking to get stronger. K.G. is one of the top 2-3 players of the past 15 years, Marion is not. He's not even in the top 25 in my book (but close). If he actually realized this, it'd save everyone a lot of writing... but, like many athletes, I honestly feel Marion needs to be recognized as the best (or his ego can't handle it).. problem is, he's not the best and he wouldn't be on half the teams in the league.
I like Marion, but these comments (IF they're true, which at this point is looking like they are) have greatly hurt the Suns chances in a trade. Now, other teams know clearly, what was once maybe just an idea, that Marion wants to go. And now the Suns are likely not going to be able to get as much in a trade as they might have...
In what may be one of Marion's last moves as a Sun, he didn't keep quiet and leave when he could've (Boston) and really helped the Suns who have paid him so much. Instead he scre.ed us and is doing it again...
If your mad about what I've written... think of this... K.Thomas didn't say stuff like this and hurt us, he was and is a professional and has acted like one during his entire stay here, and while leaving. K.Thomas will always have my respect, he's someone that if I see him on a plane, I'll get very excited to know that I've just met a pro player and a good man...There's more to being an nba player than just skills, you need to act professional and realize it's a business and no one is beyond being traded.
Sad day for Suns fans, seems we have a few players who don't know (and haven't been taught, or won't learn) how to handle the media. Look at Nash, even he was civil with Cuban during the trade. It was only after Cuban started making very public statements on tv that Nash responded... Nash was willing to be quiet and professional, Cuban doesn't know what the word is..
by jasonsuns1 on Sep 26, 2007 8:31 AM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Trade him!
by Aluminum Foyle on Sep 26, 2007 7:41 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Get him out...
I don't see where the Suns are in the wrong here. Is it because they won't give Shawn an extension of $60 million over 3 years (reported by Paul Coro)? He's already making $17 million. That's more than any player on the Suns and the 12th highest in the league. Is he really the 12th best player in the league? Is he the best player on the Suns? Is he even the 2nd best?
I've given the benefit of the doubt to Shawn for a long time. But when he's giving up the opportunity to play with Steve, Amare, Grant, Raja and Boris by requesting a trade, I think it is Shawn who has the problem. Not the rest of the guys.
Shawn says, "I haven't done anything wrong. I leave it on the floor night in and night out." Does he really? And, if he does, is that enough? Basketball is a team sport. So is just going out and playing hard enough? Or do you need to respect your teammates and realize that maybe, just maybe, they have something they can offer you?
According to Coro's article, Shawn says he doesn't have a problem with any players but won't talk about any staffers. So despite him saying the Suns' unwillingness to extend his deal is only part of the reason he wants to leave, his comments about management makes it seem like the extension is a bigger reason than he's admitting.
He says he leaves it on the floor night in and night out. Yet he is the only Suns player (don't forget about being the highest paid player) who hasn't showed up for anything this summer. Seems to me that if you're on a team, you participate with the team. If nothing else, his not showing up until he absolutely has to just tells his teammates that he's expecting them to work hard during the summer but that he's above that.
I hope the Suns trade Shawn soon and I hope it's not to the Lakers - if only because that's where he wants to go. Then again, maybe the Suns should trade him to the Lakers and make him realize how good he had it playing with Steve. If he thinks he doesn't get the ball enough and doesn't get enough credit in Phoenix, just wait until he's in LA and Kobe gets all the credit (and takes all the shots).
If they can get rid of him before training camp, even better. Then the team can focus on the team instead of on what seems to be a very selfish player.
by baller on Sep 26, 2007 9:21 AM MDT reply actions 0 recs
USA Today Effect
This makes me think that the Matrix is not the sharpest tool in the shed (yes, I know he's not a rocket surgeon, but I'm talking relative to other ballers). Does he just read the headlines and the captions under the photos? I suppose someone who watches cartoons all of his adult life might have problems thinking deeply about something.
All of this reminds me of a quote from Howard Cosell, "He's widely regarded as the most under-rated running back in football." Shawn's moved past being under-rated. That stopped a little while ago (although the All-Defensive Team snubs are inexcusable).
I'm one of his biggest defenders and his biggest fans, but WTF? I'll have to work several lifetimes to make what he makes in a year but I still shell out a significant portion of my funds to go watch him dunk over Nowitzki's head. Everyone in town loves what he does on the court and he's the highest paid player on the team.
And, you know, STAT's looking even smarter. When asked if the trade rumors bothered him, he said, "No. That means the other teams want me." He said it was a compliment to be mentioned in the same sentence as KG (something to that effect).
I think STAT and Odom in the post, with Hill and Bell on the wings would be a great offense. The Suns may not get all the threes and all the dunks, but the Suns would have a strong offense and still be able to run.
And I'll tell you another thing: Odom has incredible heart. Having a couple of young kids and thinking about his situation is heart-breaking. On the one hand, goofy Matrix is laughing off missing a free throw and this guy is playing through a torn labrum and a torn life.
When its all done, though, it's going to be tough to move him before next week. If he doesn't move, he'll show up and do his thing, playing for his $20M next year. That could be a good thing; he plays better when he gins up the feeling that he's been slighted.
by JSun on Sep 26, 2007 10:11 AM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Odom
by TexSUN on Sep 26, 2007 10:45 AM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
i agree
Let me look and see... Odom is getting .. $13 milion...
by jasonsuns1 on Sep 26, 2007 10:58 AM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
this bothers me also
"I haven't done anything wrong. I leave it on the floor night in and night out," Marion said. "Sometimes it's just time to move on."
I haven't done anything wrong, it's like he feels he's being punished by being mentioned in trade talks. This is the root of the problem, not money, this. And this is a joke, wake up Marion, it's a business, it's not like your selling your children or something, it's a game, and its a business, and you've been thinking of it in another way.
Also, you hurt the Suns by killing the K.G. deal, so don't act all innocent, but, for $23 million, I'm beginning to be glad we didn't spend that much for K.G.
by jasonsuns1 on Sep 26, 2007 11:14 AM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Kirilenko!
Odom, I guess, has more "heart" (though I'm not sure Clippers fans would agree), but Kirilenko's mental flaws shouldn't be an issue on the Suns. He's not a selfish player; he's just fragile. We've got enough character guys already though to keep him propped up. And moreover, Kirilenko will be allowed to do exactly what makes him most happy on the Suns (run and roam from the 4). And when he's happy, he's a dominant (without the ball, more importantly). You can't say that about Odom. He doesn't have that upside.
No question here: Talent over heart. Kirilenko's the man.
by rosewood on Sep 26, 2007 11:23 AM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Train Wreck
Problem with Utah is that Marion will threaten to opt-out there, too, like he did with Boston.
Part of me wants to see what AK can do in Phoenix. Bill Simmons agrees, for anyone who cares and wants to go over there and look. That guy has a really ugly offense, though.
If we can somehow dump Banks into the deal, I'd be good with that. Maybe they can cut that kind of a deal.
I'm not normally one to speculate like this, but it's killing me. For now, I'll just have to guess/hope that he shows up and plays this like a contract year.
by JSun on Sep 26, 2007 1:46 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Bill Simmons article
by TexSUN on Sep 26, 2007 2:17 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Bias
I don't think any one will agree with me on that (not even Bill Simmons apparently), but I've just had a huge man-crush on AK since '03 when he started throwing down 5x5s. That's just ridiculous, though not as ridiculous as his 5x6 two years ago (14 pts, 8 rebounds, 9 assists, 6 steals, and 7 blocks). Who does that?
Only AK and Olajuwon, because it's only been done twice in NBA history.
Andrei! Andrei! Andrei!
Like I said, it's a man-crush.
by rosewood on Sep 26, 2007 2:34 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
blah
I can't help but feel that the loss of Marion is really going to hurt. In the playoffs I bought a copy of Slam with Marion, Nash, and STAT on the cover. When we lost to SA, I almost threw the mag away because I just knew that it would be outdated. The big 3 wouldn't play together again.
Then we traded KT and I felt we had one more shot with this nucleus. Nash's comment at the end of the season, about how each of his 3 years with the Suns felt like 3 different teams and that they didn't have a chance to build off of the team before, it felt like this would be an oppurtunity to keep the team intact and actually improve from mistakes in the past. I found that Slam mag the other day and actually framed it in a cheap 2 dollar frame. I guess I just jinxed it...
At this point I don't care even if it's AK 47. I'm talking myself into it. I just want Marion gone so the team has time to gel. But he's certainly not doing the Suns any favors by bringing this garbage up this late in the offseason.
Name one clutch shot Marion ever made. The biggest plays I can think of off the top of my head are when he got the rebound and passed to Tim Thomas, when he got the rebound and passed to Nash at the end of that reg season game against the Mavs, and...
He needed to win that Game 5 against the Spurs. He had 20 by halftime, then you couldn't find him. He had a chance to make a 3 at the end, but it was errant.
Then he nixed a trade for KG. That would have been the most clutch play of all.
by kidjay on Sep 26, 2007 11:32 AM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Bring on Odom!
Any trade needs to happen before camp opens, if it's going to happen.
Also, what's this about his issues with the "front office"? Apparently, he loves the teammates, the coaches, the city and the fans, but not the "front office." You mean the "front office" that gave you the fattest contract on the team?
Anyway, here'a link to Odom's stats:
http://sports.espn.go.com/nba/players/profile?playerId=0617
When he's healthy, he's playing close to 40 minutes a game. We know he brings it in the playoffs, and perhaps the Suns training staff could help him out.
I'm warming up to the idea of Odom and STAT in the lane. Things could be a lot worse ...
by JSun on Sep 26, 2007 11:52 AM MDT reply actions 0 recs
I hope our Front Office lays low for awhile
If Kerr reacts right away, it would make our organization look desperate to get something/anything for Marion... thereby not getting a player they'd want -- who could contribute immediately -- in return.
Privately, they should talk to Matrix, but by no means should they publicly respond with any outrageous statements.
Just my take.
If Shawn wants out, let's see who or whom we can get for him.
Otherwise, he is still under contract.
by kcbrett5 on Sep 26, 2007 12:04 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
LA vs Utah vs Some Eastern Conf Team
I don't like either option of doing a deal w/ LA or Utah. In Utah though Marion combined w/ Boozer, D Will and Okur would make those guys a real contender. They were good last year and with Marion's athletic abilities would be a LOT better.
LA on the other hand w/ Marion instead of Odom would be about the same if not worse. They need an inside presense in the worst way and Marion doesn't bring that. On the flip side, as much as I love Odom, we need to get more then him in return.
So, I think the front office should be talking to teams in the East. Maybe in a three way deal, but at the end of the day Marion needs to be in Atlanta or Charolette and not in a WC rival.
We also need to be getting back a player that can fulfill a similar role which is mainly the ability to run and finish and defend positions from at least the 2 to the 4.
by Phoenix Stan on Sep 26, 2007 2:51 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Dump Banks
If they can't package a deal with Banks, I hope they'll keep him and I'm relatively sure we'll have a good season.
by JSun on Sep 26, 2007 3:04 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Banks in Utah
So, AK47 + Milsap for Banks and Marion?
I guess I wouldn't jump off a bridge.
But still, Marion in Utah scares the crap out of me.
I think the best option is to look at 3 way deals that send Marion to LA and Odom and whatever somewhere else and get us back...well, that's still the big question but there's got to be some good options out there. Time to start up the trade machine and looking at options again.
by Phoenix Stan on Sep 26, 2007 3:17 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
I might jump of a bride
I think, though, that Matrix going to Utah is a lot more dangerous for the Suns than him playing in LA. Ball-hog Kobe or a good PG? Marion playing the 3 with other scorers and two big men vs. Luke Walton?
Plus, Odom's contract is less than AK's and expires in 2 years (AK's is 4). With's KT's absence, I'd kind of like to see Odom here, too.
by JSun on Sep 26, 2007 3:21 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Marion in Utah
He'll still produce but his production will go down because:
- He'll have to play SF, where he's not as effective because he can't simply outrun his opponents (Remember he generally plays PF for Phoenix). It also exposes his weak ball handling and streaky shot.
- Utah runs more than they used to, but they're still primarily a half-court team. That doesn't work for Shawn at all. The only things he does well in the half-court are rebound, defend, and sometimes an awkward floater through the lane.
by rosewood on Sep 26, 2007 3:30 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
But, Utah showed they can run
by Phoenix Stan on Sep 26, 2007 3:57 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Maybe
So sure, like I said, they run more than they used to, but not like the Suns and so Marion's production will suffer. Because I don't think he can score consistently as a 3 in a half-court offense. He doesn't have the game for it.
by rosewood on Sep 26, 2007 4:14 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
You could say that
I guess my fear would be in Utah they would have both the ability to run their p/r in the half court and also an increased ability to run as well. Any championship team needs to be able to do both these days. Especially, in the West.
by Phoenix Stan on Sep 26, 2007 4:40 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
It's All About Chemistry
It could be exciting...though I admit that it's easier to say that from afar than it is to be in Phoenix right now being immersed in it.
Marion wants to leave. I wish him well and hope he regrets it by the end of the upcoming season.
by Sunny on Sep 26, 2007 3:08 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
AK is better than Odom
Comparing AK to Odom:
-Both Injury Prones. Don't know which one is worse.
- AK much better defender, better than Marion too.
- Both good passers.
- Odom better shooter and scorer overall, but AK playing in the 4 is a good scorer too.
by Bruno on Sep 26, 2007 3:36 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
More Bride Jumping
I'm going down to the Arena to get a custom-made Odom-Suns replica jersey outside the the Team Shop. I need something else, especially since right now I've only got a Burke hanging in my closet.
by JSun on Sep 26, 2007 3:59 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
I still wear my...
and btw..I am not sure "bride" jumping was a typo or some other kind of slip
by Phoenix Stan on Sep 26, 2007 4:06 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Another Aspect of a Trade With Utah
Ronnie Brewer.
1.75 mil, easy to go along with AK for a Marion/Banks swap. Here's his scouting report from ESPN.com:
"Scouting report: Utah's recent drafts have churned out plenty of dubious players, but Brewer may be the exception. His athleticism is beyond question, and his ballhandling skills are also well above the norm for a 6-7 shooting guard.
The question mark is his shooting ability. Brewer had mediocre numbers from outside as a collegian and has a funky release as a result of a childhood injury. But scouts think he'll be a great defender, and his steals rate as a collegian backs that up. Plus, Brewer couldn't move into a better situation. Utah basically has an open spot at shooting guard, so if he shows any promise whatsoever he'll probably start."
hmmm...awkward release...athleticism...6'7''...
And oh, yeah, Utah doesn't want him so much because of the glory that is Deron Williams for them. Their backcourt is pretty much set. This would be a steal for us. Getting Brewer and AK essentially means we upgrade Marion's rebounding and shotblocking with AK, and ballhandling, hustle, defense, and potentially some scoring with Brewer.
And he's a second year guy with an expiring contract. Worst case scenario we pick him up with Giricek's 4mil expiring and we've got an extra 7 mil in cap room next year.
This trade works on both ESPN's trade machine and RealGM's trade checker.
by Ridiculous Matt on Sep 26, 2007 4:39 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Backcourt set?
So now they have to find a replacement btw Giricek, Brewer, and Morris Almond. I'd say Brewer is the favorite for that spot. At worst, he'll be platooning with Giricek.
by rosewood on Sep 26, 2007 5:30 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Here's why I love Steve Nash and Raja Bell
D'Antoni has some nice words too:
by TexSUN on Sep 26, 2007 5:08 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
The Tribune is the rant exception
If Kerr and Co. & Matrix (along with the obviously obtuse majority of the fans in general - or maybe it's just me being more familiar with the media and its tactics) do the right thing by giving the proverbial finger to the media at large, they ought to be able to iron this crap out.
All I know is that this kind of bullshit never happened under the Colangelo reign - at the very least, despite obvious mistakes, they kept the media at large up on their damn perch instead of up everyone's ass with a microscope.
Now, to Matrix and the brass: Iron this crap out PDQ. Your teammates obviously want you back.....
by SwingMan on Sep 26, 2007 9:35 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Like I said
But remember that during the Colangelo era we didn't have the proliferation of sports talk radio, online sporting news and sports blogging.
by JSun on Sep 27, 2007 10:59 AM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Video from Raja
by TexSUN on Sep 26, 2007 11:37 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Torn Up
But from his shoes I understand his frustration. But he should know better. Rumors are nothing more than rumors, unreliable, unpredictable crap that rarely has any validity to it. As for the front office not talking about an extention, thats reasonable on the front office's part. They need to keep incentive for a player to keep his game up.
So for once this really is not the front office's fault, but that of a player who has looked at things at a slanted view. I'll still miss him, but its best that he go. This comment will only be a year long distraction. Its so sad that he had to go public with it.
by PurplePinoy on Sep 27, 2007 12:29 AM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Don't assume
by SwingMan on Sep 27, 2007 12:54 AM MDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 















