Social Issues and Basketball
It’s really rare –and dangerous- when we get to talk about basketball and social problems in the same article. Part of me was telling me to leave this alone, but I just couldn’t. I want to share my thoughts on the latest news from Beijing, where the headline reads: Spanish Basketball Team poses for an offensive picture.
Apparently some genius decided that I would be cool and funny to have Spain’s Basketball Team pose for an ad picture where all of them are slanting their eyes. Cool? Funny? Far from it.
What’s even more surprising is that no one from the Spanish Team thinks that the ad is offensive.
José Calderón said the following: "We did it because we thought it was going to be something nice, something with no problem, But somebody wants to talk about it. It is too much of a big deal with you guys (the media) and everybody talking about that."
Wait a second… did he just say nice? NICE? Calderón has been in United States for 3 years now; I assume that he speaks fairly good English, therefore, I can also assume the he is just plain dumb. Well, you can’t expect elaborated and intelligent answers from players when their head coach Aíto García Reneses says something like this:
"If I go to play with a taller team and I put here (rising up on the tips of his toes) it is not an offense," "I can’t understand anything more."
Well, at least he is right about something! And by the way… when did being tall become a racial distinction? The comparison is stupid to say the least. Sure, Chinese people tend to be short of size, but it’s not something that applies to every Chinese men or women. Look at Yao for God sake!
People might say that the media is blowing things out of proportion, as usual, but I think that if someone mocks a whole Continent, they are going to have to live with it.
Spanish sports are no strangers to racial controversy. Heck, the country itself is not a stranger to racial controversy.
Luis Aragones, the head coach of Spain’s men’s soccer team, was overheard telling his player Jose Antonio Reyes to "tell that black (expletive) you are better than him" back in 2004. He was referring to Thierry Henry from France.
At an exhibition match in Madrid in 2004, several black members of the England men’s soccer team were subjected to monkey chants and whistles whenever they touched the ball.
The immigration rate in Spain is increasing by the minute, Rumanians, Africans, Latin Americans, and Gypsies are going to Spain, looking for a better life. They dislike Americans and ironically their situation is really close to what happens in United States (immigration wise). You will see in the news whenever an immigrant does something wrong, shoplifting, street fighting, domestic disputes. Everything is shown with extreme detail and even exaggeration. This creates a constant paranoia and prejudice that is really palpable.
I happen to know all this because I went to Spain last December and stayed there for a month. My wife and I experienced a bunch of things that are not even worth mentioning in detail. Things like being stared at in the Metro, mistreated at restaurants, being stopped on the streets several times by the Police. My wife was not enjoying this trip at all, and I was starting to get pissed. I decide to downplay everything and try to enjoy our stay. But on New Year’s Eve, we decided to go to a fancy restaurant, I ordered the Wine Menu and the waiter seemed to be really surprised by my request, eyes fixed on mine, tilting his head to one side like a dog who’s not understanding his master’s orders. He smiles and says he is going to bring it over. After a few minutes I overheard his conversation with another waiter, he was saying that he couldn’t understand how I was able to afford eating in a place like that and that he didn’t get how a "Sudaca" (which is a derogatory term for South American) would know about wines. After we finished eating, I called him over and said to him in, a really low voice, almost whispering, that the reason I knew about wines was because a Spaniard had come to my house when I was young, asking for a job and something to eat and we took him in and he taught me about wines.
Well, enough with my stories, The Chinese had the chance to beat Spain on the court, but failed to do so in overtime. But at least the crowd booed their asses off the place.
Spain is a beautiful country, I can’t say that all Spaniards are like that, I met wonderful people while I was there, they were the minority, but that makes them stand out even more.
Spain has been exposed in the most important sports event of the year, it’s a shame that they don’t recognize their mistake and apologize.
21 comments
|
recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Maybe ...
I’m torn just because (a) it was inappropriate, but (b) it’s so stupid. I’m trying to understand where you’re coming from, Panama, and I think I can (of course, I’m restricted by being an upper-middle class white male) but to me it is a non-issue.
Spain’s attempt to make it seem like a “friendly gesture” is the only thing more stupid than the original photo. That sort of thing is something that mature adults left behind in elementary school.
I guess it’s more of an indictment of them than anything else. Overly-negative reaction to it only give the Spanish what they wanted (like in grade school).
I do remember the soccer stuff, though. I had a friend at a match in France that said similar things happened, too.
Perhaps the dumbest thing about it is that the Chinese are not “invading” Spain in the same manner that the Spanish perceive the “invasions” from the Africans, etc.
Mmmmm ... Guinness
I wonder
if Pau will use this to make Sun Yue feel welcome on the Lakers.
Also: I do love the fact that the Spanish are justifying this by also pointing to a picture of the Lithuanian players posing as bullfighters.
Last: I’d have to agree with JSun, in that this is undoubtedly offensive, but it’s so stupid and so typical of Euro-xenophobia that I didn’t pay it much mind. It’s kind of like when one of our athletes makes yet another homophobic/sexist remark (or just beats his wife. Way to be, JKidd!).
Professional basketball players and social awareness are just not a common combination, which isn’t that surprising when you give men who have been idolized since grade school millions of dollars to play a child’s game and tell them they’re heroes.
Purchasing my Dragic jersey
Thanks, Panama
Issue of non-issue, one of the most difficult things we have to leaarn to get along in this world is how to treat other people. This happens everywhere, but of course there are those that only see bad treatment when it is done to someone outside a definable group. Which of course is myopic.
I have done nothing overt to deserve the hatred and derision of Europeans, yet I have been treated with disdain and prejudice wherever I went in Europe (I know, some of you might say this is Bush’s fault, but I was there in 1987). It is a nice place, but I would not want to live there. I had a discussion with a Danish guy who pretty much painted all Americans with the same brush; we didn’t ‘care’ for our people since our government didn’t provide everything free from cradle to grave.
Also, I wonder if there is a distinct prejudice for South Americans on the continent. I was in Brussells, and some Colombian musicicians were treated horribly by a skinhead gang (which, by the way, are everywhere). I wanted to do something, but was limited by language.
These Spanish players are idiots, to be sure. I think in the competitive world of sports that is dominated by the young and foolish, we will inevitably see this kind of thing. You ought to see what passes as a ‘joke’ on a high school campus here in the States. My wife is a high school teacher, and had a colleague that missed a semester with a nervous breakdown. We came to find out that it was a game for these students to see if they could harass a teacher into a breakdown. In Mao’s China, students turned in teachers in for ‘Communist’ activities (often resulting in torture an/or death) when all they did is dare to give a student a failing grade.
In a world where this can happen, does it surprise you what these players did? Those who condemn it need to condemn it wherever it occurs.
April 29, 2008 Total Eclipse of the Sun. Is the sky falling?
correction: should have been 'anti-Communist' activities
Mao wouldn’t arrest anyone for Communist activities, although Mao was not averse to turning on his own to achieve political power
April 29, 2008 Total Eclipse of the Sun. Is the sky falling?
Takes me back...
Being of East Asian background, more than offended by Spanish team and the photographer’s actions (and reactions), they just seem pathetic.
Haven’t seen anyone do the ‘slanted eyes’ thing since kindergarten, when some classmates were trying to taunt me. ...We all were, what, 4 years old?
BTW, José Calderón plays point guard for the Toronto Raptors. He’s their defacto starting point guard, now that they traded TJ Ford, yeah?
Toronto’s a multicultural city with a large and vibrant Chinese community. Bryan Colangelo & the Raptors PR department might not be in their happy place right now.
Are there a few Asians in LA, too?
If anyone was looking for another adjective to define the picture, how about “infantile?”
Regardless, it seems to me this was only a moment of “nonthinking” on the part of these basketball players as opposed to some deeply rooted racism coming to the surface. Everyone has them. We all can think of and name 100 recent public embarassments (Don Imus anyone?) relative to racist comments and such.
I doubt anyone can say anything to make the Spanish team feel any worse or stupid than they already do. And if they do not feel bad, then we should all feel sorry for them.
Sure we all have stories of Europeans treating Americans like garbage and I am sure they can say the same. People tend to take one or two instances of rudeness and paint a whole culture or race. It’s been going on for a long time and will always, I believe, because there is more that divides us than brings us together.
The Sun fan in me though is happy that Gasol was in that picture. Another reason to dislike the Lakers!
"I think people should be allowed to do anything they want. We haven't tried that for a while. Maybe this time it'll work." -George Carlin
Way late to the party...
…but I’m going to agree with RD74. The photo is admittedly stupid. However, I think it was done in relative innocence. There would be no outcry if the players had donned blond wigs for Stockholm games or funny hats with dreadlocks for the Kingston games.
Great post
I’m a Spurs fan, and I know that makes me you guy’s mortal enemy, but this is a great post dude. This racism is killing me!!!
It's never just a game when you're winning. - George Carlin
Sorry
I’m eurasian.
I don’t find it neither racist, nor anything that you guys are saying.
Definitely a bad advertisement.
Guys, the one on the right hand side, on the floor (Carlos Jimenez ?), seem’s to me like his fingers are in his ears…
Sorry, but people calling Kaman a traitor make me far more uncomfortable.
It’s just plain stupid.
C'Mon
This is a bit much isn’t it? Basketball, the Suns, and particularly a blog about the Suns should be fun. I think getting on a soapbox about something as unrelated as this is pretty weak man. I think a lot of this sites visitors probably feel the same way I do about this post, too. Rant about the Spurs, Stern, Donaghy, Kobe, Jackson, the Lakers.
by MichiganSunsFan on Aug 14, 2008 11:18 PM MDT reply actions
It's August
I think it’s just cool that Panama is posting at all. If you want something else, there’s a whole fanpost column to your left that you’re free to contibute to.
Purchasing my Dragic jersey
I think people are not getting the point of my post
Fist of all, the post is about basketball, and its all over the internet…not just here. I decided to write about it because of my experience while I was there. Just to be clear, I’m not bitter or have thin skin…this is an informative post. You are asking me to “Rant” about the Spurs..Kobe.. etc.. Well in case you haven’ t notice, Gasol is in this picture.
You want read something fun? feel free to write something in the fanposts so we can all be entertained.
"Basketball doesn't build character. It reveals it"
I said "stupid" a lot
But I don’t want it to be misconstrued.
The move was stupid, the joke was not funny, over-reaction to it is stupid, the comment that it was meant as a friendly gesture is more stupid than the original photo.
The post itself? Actually, I was interested to read about your experiences.
Mmmmm ... Guinness
Not Really
I think it merits discussion … some discussion, not a lot.
Isn’t a blog a place where persons write about things they think about or relate to?
Mmmmm ... Guinness
postworthy or not
We will quit talking about this long before we approach the time spent ruminating about whose fault it was to lose JJ, or when Matrix would be traded.
April 29, 2008 Total Eclipse of the Sun. Is the sky falling?
Racism? I think not.
Racism is prejudice or discrimination based on the belief that race is the primary factor determining human traits and abilities. Racism includes the belief that genetic or inherited differences produce the inherent superiority or inferiority of one race over another.
The key factor in determining racism is the extent to which the action in question involves or results in discrimination or judgment of superiority/inferiority. I just don’t see that here. Is the pose childish and in poor taste? Probably. Would the Spanish be pissed if they were hosting the games and other teams took photos dressed as matadors? Probably. But what is the message this photo is really sending? That the Spanish think that Chinese people have eyes that are shaped differently than theirs?
Let me be clear: racism is a hideous blight, to be spoken out against and eradicated. This? This is nonsense.
Wrong Message
The message isn’t that “the Spanish think that Chinese people have eyes that are shaped differently than theirs.”
The message is that the physical characteristics of Asians are laughable. That’s racism in its simplest form.
Purchasing my Dragic jersey
I want to ask permission
Next Season, every PHX SUN in my photos will have TP Coneheads.
Will that be okay with everyone?
=)
Wondering what the skip-2-my-loo to do next with my empty summer





















