The Putz vs. the Putz Master
I don't mean to throw a wet blanket on the party, and no one is in the mood to be upset, so I should probably archive this for posting at a later date, but the story just came out, and I'm really in the mood for run-on sentences with excessive punctuation.
Now, Stern's getting serious. We can't have anyone else complaining. If anyone complains, it might show a chink in the armor.
No need to improve the quality of the officiating, I've got a better idea for those who complain:
So, it's about time that Phil Jackson shut up?
"I wish I had it to do all over again and, starting 20 years ago, I’d be suspending Phil and Pat Riley for all the games they play in the media," Stern said in a press conference ...
The thing is that Stern is agreeing and conceding that the NBA officials cannot stay unbiased. He doesn't say, "Hey, it's an unwelcome part of the game that deserves a fine, but our offiicials aren't swayed by it." He doesn't say, "For all the complaining that goes on, our fans know that the refs do the best they can." No, he blames the public perception of the officials on a small group of complainers -- and it is small; every time someone speaks up, they lose money.
He says,
They [the players and coaches who donate their salaries for speaking] give the impression to our fans that referees somehow have an agenda.
The impression that there is an agenda comes from the league for not admitting its problems.
Does LeBron get the calls? Yes. Is it an agenda or psychology? Well, human beings are primed to look at the results and then work backward to figure out what happened. So, when Channing Frye jumps straight up he gets called for a foul if the offensive player misses, but when James brings his hands and arms down after the jump it is a great defensive play. We expect Frye to commit the foul because he's a soft defender and a big-man shooting 3s. We expect LeBron to make the play because he's a talented stud.
What to do? What to do? Stern would sweep psychology under the rug. Fans call it an agenda. I would suggest honestly analyzing human frailities (self-deprecation got Reagan into the White House), being honest with the supporters of the NBA (the persons paying) and working on the issues.
However, mandating respect in the form of monetary sanctions rarely works. Respect is earned, not forcibly extracted.
How do you earn respect? An honest, transparent effort at a consistent application of the rules. For example, if leaving the bench gets you a game suspension, perhaps throwing an elbow to another player's chops should result in a two-game suspension. Or, better yet, grabbing an official during an on-court melee should result in at least a game's suspension.
As another example, look at "tough, physical" playoff games. The argument is that if the refs called it the same as in the regular season, then a whole canoe-full of players would be on the bench gettin' paddled. Then, we'd be in a horrible situation because the coaches would have to put fans in uniforms to play the games. Forget about the low quality of the games, can you imagine how many lawsuits would be filed by fans when the complained that they were stupid when they voluntarily stepped on the court without so much as a warning from the league? How many games would be lost before those stupid players, coaches and front office personnel figured out they needed to tell their multi-millionaire athletes to follow the same rules in the regular season as in the post-season?
I'm not saying the game should be called one way or the other. I'm just saying to call it the same.
And, I don't know if this occurs, but I'm also saying that officials are just like any other human being and need training and repitition as opposed to just being told what they've done wrong behind closed doors after a game.
Actually, though, Stern is right about one thing -- if he had been a man about back then, the fans would've had a lot less of Phil Jackson to put up with. He couldn't even do that one thing for me, could he?
13 comments
|
6 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Can we paddle David Stern???
Seriosly a good story, but as long as yu have the human element in it, there will be bias…Maybe we train some officials from the back woods of Bornea that don’t have any bias, but they soon would be tarnished by McDonald’s cheeseburgers and 22" rims…
What can a team without a marquee name do, except enjoy the “ride?”
"The art of war is simple enough. Find out where your enemy is. Get at him as soon as you can. Strike him as hard as you can, and keep moving."
Ulysses S Grant
There will always be bias
I’m just saying that denial is not the way to deal with it. Hard to being to work on fixing something while you’re telling everyone else it does not exist.
And, I get to relive the paddlin’
Mmmmm ... Guinness
Good Post -Rec'd-
I agree with you. Refs have a tough job to do but trying to hide their mistakes or force people not to mention them is wrong. The “Super Star treatment” exists. Period. They will call fouls against rookies that they would never call against a star. Look at Dragic last year, he would never catch a break from a ref.
"Basketball doesn't build character. It reveals it"
Players and coaches
believe it…they talk about it all the time. Off the record.
Blogging Suns Basketball . twitter: @sethpo
by Seth Pollack on Apr 23, 2010 1:33 PM MST up reply actions
Czar Stern
Likes to censor speech in the media but not on the court. I don’t get it. LeBron can bitch like a pre-pubescent woman during games until he gets the calls he likes, but after the game if anyone says anything to David’s dislike then their in trouble. Weird.
Blogging Suns Basketball. Twitter: @willcantrellphx
by Wil Cantrell on Apr 24, 2010 10:15 AM MST up reply actions
Personally, I feel that is an area that really needs to be cleaned up...
As a fan, you regularly can see players and coaches working a ref during the game and how his officiating adjusts accordingly…
"The art of war is simple enough. Find out where your enemy is. Get at him as soon as you can. Strike him as hard as you can, and keep moving."
Ulysses S Grant
Reced for not only having an alternative opinion but also having one of the better Simpsons gags.
by 8472species on Apr 23, 2010 1:47 PM MST reply actions
my opinion
Personally, I don’t sympathize with Stern’s position or the complainers’ position. I accept mistakes by referees as a fact of life. Complaining is useless; teams must play well enough to beat both the other team and the system. There’s no other choice. The fact that Stern is a smug, money-grubbing slimeball doesn’t change it.
by 8472species on Apr 23, 2010 2:06 PM MST reply actions
Great post. Wreck'd. This is one subject Blazer fans AND Suns fans can certianly agree on.
Also, one of my favorite Simpsons episodes.
"What people need to know is that those pictures were taken a year and a half ago, and I've grown since then." - Greg Oden























