clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Bright Side 2013 Community Mock Draft: Grade time

After a whirling dervish of a mock that included 35 (yes, 35) trades I was implored, or maybe just asked in passing, to sift through the rubble and provide some quick grades. Due to the nature of clock ticking tumult not all of my takes will be as thoroughly researched as some of the participants moves (since I didn't have 20-30 hours to work on this), but I will try to do my best.

The Brightside's #1 overall pick...
The Brightside's #1 overall pick...

Atlanta Hawks - stevedavis_

Out: DeShawn Stevenson, Lou Williams, John Jenkins, Mike Scott, #17, #18

In: Thomas Robinson, Wes Matthews, Greg Steimsma, Kelly Olynyk (26)

The Hawks added about $3.5 million to their cap number, which poised them to be a big player in free agency, while not significantly adding to their young talent. Matthews is a slighlty more expensive/slightly better replacement for Williams, Robinson is a calculated gamble and Olynyk (a top 20 talent) is great value at 26... but the moves appear mostly lateral for a team that currently lacks a definitive identity.

Grade: B-

Boston Celtics - arvin123

Out: Kevin Garnett, Jason Terry, Courtney Lee

In: DeAndre Jordan, Caron Butler, Willie Green, Gorgui Dieng (16), Ricky Ledo (25)

The Celtics transition from one era to the next is looking painful. The Celtics didn't lose much in these deals, considering Garnett is 36 and Terry is 35, but didn't really improve either. $11 million for nine points and seven rebounds a game (Jordan) isn't wise resource allocation. The trades give Boston a little bit of cap relief after next season, but a straight salary dump would have been preferable. Dieng isn't a reach at 16, but Ledo at 25 probably is.

Grade: C-

Brooklyn Nets - Richard Bowman

Out: Brook Lopez, Reggie Evans, Marshon Brooks

In: Javale McGee, Kosta Koufos, Andre Miller, Anthony Randolph, Tim Hardaway Jr. (22), Lucas Nogueira (27)

Usually the team who gets the best player wins the trade. The 25 year old Lopez was the best player in this trade, so read between the lines. Or I'll just lay it out. The Nets took a major frontcourt hit without a significant upgrade at any other position. Hardaway is a reach at 22, but Nogueira is an interesting prospect that could be a steal at 27. Still... trading a franchise center is fairly indefensible. Brooklyn basically dealt a steak for three chicken wings.

Grade: D

Charlotte Bobcats - sunfromunder

In: Victor Oladipo (4)

Never confuse activity with achievement. Charlotte gained positive momentum by standing still. The Bobcats may have come away with the best player in this draft class while continuing to build around a young core... that has them poised to compete for another top five pick next season.

Grade: A

Chicago Bulls -babypa

In: Mason Plumlee (20)

Plumlee is a solid value at this pick and fills a need in Chicago's frontcourt, with Joakim Noah the only center on the team under contract next season. Mason will likely be able to step in right away and contribute in spot minutes behind Noah. This is a situation where BPA and need complement each other.

Grade: B+

Cleveland Cavaliers - Suns Fan For Life

Out: Anderson Varejao, Dion Waiters, Alonzo Gee, #19

In: Lou Williams, Jeremy Lamb, Will Barton, Trevor Ariza, C.J. McCollum (6), Otto Porter Jr. (1), #40

With Varejao out the door, and no bigs returning from a bevy of moves, Tyler Zeller becomes Cleveland's full time starting center. Yes, the same Zeller that averaged eight points and six rebounds a game last year while shooting 44%. His backup... *crickets chirping* The Cavs roster is now set at the guard and wings position, but leaves Tristan Thompson to play all the minutes at the four and five. I'd rather take a big #1 and Porter would probably still be available at #3. Despite my infatuation with McCollum the overall picture is kind of muddled. Maybe free agency or future trades can help balance the roster but... Kyrie Irving is probably pretty stunned right now.

Grade: C-

Dallas Mavericks - jc79

Out: Shawn Marion, Vince Carter, rights to Petteri Kaponen, rights to Nick Calathes, #13, $3 million

In: John Henson

Dallas achieves its salary dump AND returns the best player in the deal. Hard not to see this as a coup for Dallas... except for the fact that they still owe ~$23 million to a declining 35 year old and will probably strike out with their $30 million in free agency cap room.

Grade: B+

Denver Nuggets - BringBarkley17

Out: Javale McGee, Kosta Koufos, Andre Miller, Anthony Randolph, #27

In: Brook Lopez, Reggie Evans, Marshon Brooks

The Nuggets turn a quartet of average to below players into a top five center (who might be better than anybody taken in this year's draft). Seems like a big win even though I don't think Lopez is the best fit for the Nuggets style. Then again, who knows what the Nuggets style is with the hiring of new head coach Brian Shaw.

Grade: A

Detroit Pistons - nateman48

Out: Brandon Knight, Rodney Stuckey, Jonas Jerebko, Viacheslav Kravstov, Kentavious Caldwell-Pope (8)

In: Danny Granger, Lance Stephenson, George Hill, Tony Mitchell (23)

The backcourt of Stephenson and Hill is an upgrade, but swapping from eight to 23 for the pleasure of one year (~$14 million) of a 30 year old question mark in Granger seems suspect. If he can play and produce the Pistons might find a way into the playoffs as a lower seed, but he could also become an expiring deal at the deadline. Mitchell fits the profile of a high ceiling risk, but the Pistons would probably be better off biding their time and building around a young core.

Grade: D+

Houston Rockets - jc79

Out: Thomas Robinson

In: DeShawn Stevenson, Giannis Adetokunbo (18)

Adetokunbo is an 18 year old project that won't be able to contribute for years and Stevenson is a roster spot with two years left on his contract. While Houston was obviously looking to move Robinson it seems like they should have been able to get something better to help win now than a crappy 32 year old journeyman.

Grade: C- B- *see comments below for grade adjustment

Indiana Pacers - khalid.h

Out: Danny Granger, Lance Stephenson, George Hill, Tony Mitchell (23)

In: Brandon Knight, Rodney Stuckey, Jonas Jerebko, Viacheslav Kravstov, Kentavious Caldwell-Pope (8)

You know those trades that end up being lose-lose. Yeah. The idea of a contending team trading two starters to go after the point guard of the future makes my brain hurt. After being one game away from the NBA Finals the Pacers' fans are definitely going to have to temper their expectations... or organize a sedition. Sometimes it's better to stay the course, especially when the Pacers entire team is 27 or younger besides David West and the returning Granger.

Grade: F

LA Clippers - blank_38

Out: DeAndre Jordan, Caron Butler, Willie Green

In: Kevin Garnett, Jason Terry, Courtney Lee, Gorgui Dieng (16), Ricky Ledo (25)

The Clippers add youth and pieces that should help them compete for a championship next year. IF Chris Paul is on board (assuming he gave his blessing) this is a great deal. PLUS I'm sure that bringing on Doc Rivers as head coach played into this decision. ;)

Grade: A+

Milwaukee Bucks - gallen89

Out: John Henson, Epke Udoh, #15

In: Shawn Marion, Vince Carter, Jae Crowder, rights to Petteri Kaponen, rights to Nick Calathes, rights to Nemanja Bjelica, Anthony Bennett (9), Tony Snell (21)

The Bucks return a hodgepodge of players that don't help the team win now but don't hurt the team moving forward. Picking up Bennett at nine is solid, but he better end up being a better pro than the precocious Henson or else this trade will probably look like a huge whiff in hindsight. Snell may also be a little bit of a reach at 21.

Grade: D+

Minnesota - STUPID KERR

Out: rights to Nemanja Bjelica, #9, #21, #52

In: John Jenkins, Mike Scott, Epke Udoh, Sergey Karasev (13), Steven Adams (15)

I'm assuming the logic behind this trade is that neither Karasev or Adams was likely to be available when the Wolves pick at #21. Rather than reaching for one at #9, they end up with both. Time will tell, but it appears that Minnesota executed their plan and got their guys.

Grade: B+

New Orleans Pelicans - hoiberg

Out: Lance Thomas, #6

In: Isaiah Thomas, Shabazz Muhammad (12)

I'm not sure I understand the quizzical rationale behind a team trading for a starting point guard who is worse than their current starting point guard. Even if Muhammad is coveted it's hard to imagine that A. there won't be a player taken between 6-11 that isn't better and B. that the Pelicans couldn't have filled a position of greater need. Not a good start for the large water birds...

Grade: D

NY Knicks - The Solution

In: Glen Rice Jr. (24)

Rice is projected as a late first/early second, so this isn't really that much of a reach... but not a value pick either (on the surface). He does fit the style of the three point bombing Knicks, though, and does fill a need as a backup three. Seems like a decent pick where the Knicks are slated.

Grade: C

Oklahoma City Thunder - jack.kremmer22

Out: Nick Collison, Jeremy Lamb, #12

In: Marcin Gortat, Mike Muscala (29), Reggie Bullock (30)

Lamb and #12 is too much for a year of Gortat. The Thunder should be able to do better (like dumping Perkins). Sam Presti must have picked the wrong week to start taking psychotropic drugs. Does this mean that the Thunder basically traded James Harden for the aging duo of Kevin Martin and Gortat? Talk about trading a dollar for two quarters.

Grade: D-

Orlando Magic - Eric Fong

Out: Glen Davis, #2

In: Channing Frye, Trey Burke (7)

If Burke is truly Orlando's man trading down makes sense... if they can get something by doing so Without a guarantee that Frye can play, however, this seems like a head scratcher. A sunk cost contract swap for the privilege of moving down five spots? Can Frye even be traded? Seems like he would have a hard time passing a physical...

Grade: D

Philadelphia 76ers - phxpurple

In: Dennis Schroeder (11)

Schroeder is a quality pick at this position, but don't expect him to get any much playing time ever behind 22 year old stud Jrue Holiday. I guess duplicating a position based on BPA isn't the worst thing, but this is a little discomfiting.

Grade: C-

Phoenix Suns - Richard Parker

Out: Marcin Gortat, Jared Dudley, Michael Beasley, Channing Frye, #30, #57

In: John Salmons, Glen Davis, Nick Collison, Danny Green, Nando de Colo, Nerlens Noel (2), Ben McLemore (5), Jamaal Franklin (19), #32

The Suns managed to walk out of this mock with Green, Noel, McLemore, Franklin AND without Beasley... which probably makes them the biggest winner in this fabricated scenario, even if Noel and McLemore weren't my top two prospects (which they are). Either the Suns new GM truly is a miracle worker, the other GMs are rubes that got fleeced, or people had an ulterior motive to help put the Suns on the fast track to rebuilding.

Grade: A+ (hmm...)

Portland Trail Blazers

Out: Nolan Smith, Wes Matthews, Will Barton, #10, #40, #45

In: Anderson Varejao, Cody Zeller (14)

After rumored interest in Marcin Gortat (or a big in general) the Blazers hit a home run instead of settling for a double. Varejao and Zeller (good value at 14) combine with LaMarcus Aldridge and Meyers Leonard to turn a suspect frontcourt into one of the strongest in the league.

Grade: A

Sacramento Kings - brawadis

Out: John Salmons, Isaiah Thomas, DeMarcus Cousins, Marcus Thornton, Jimmer Fredette, #7

In: Bradley Beal, Jared Dudley, Nene, Lance Thomas, Alex Len (3)

The Kings cleaned house by sending out the players who played that vast majority of significant minutes last season and ushering in a new cast. The biggest pieces to move in these deals were Cousins, #7, Beal and #3. Since Cousins was unlikely to be part of this team's future it seems like a big win for Sactown.

Grade: A-

San Antonio Spurs - y2kctiger

Out: Danny Green, Nando de Colo

In: Michael Beasley, Rudy Gobert (17), Allen Crabbe (28), #57

This seems like exactly the type of shrewd move the Spurs are known for... or the complete opposite. I'm not going to dignify this with a further explanation.

Grade: D-

Utah Jazz - Air Deke

Out: #14, #21

In: Nolan Smith, Michael Carter-Williams (10), #45

Utah flips picks #14 and #21 for their (potential) point guard of the future. Well played.

Grade: A-

Washington Wizards - blank_38

Out: Bradley Beal, Nene, Trevor Ariza, #3

In: DeMarcus Cousins, Marcus Thornton, Jimmer Fredette, Patrick Patterson, Dion Waiters, Alonzo Gee

The Wiz got six players to fill out a rotation around Wall, Webster and Okafor, but this trade seems hard to gauge without knowing how the Beal/Len - Cousins/Waiters swap plays out. I tend to like the stability and (slightly) ceiling of Beal/Len better so I count this as a loss. John Wall is probably calling Kyrie Irving right now having a WTF conversation.

Grade: C-


So there you have it. Remember that I'm grading these moves as an impartial (somewhat) bystander that has not followed any of these proceedings up to this point. I have no idea of any of the discussions or mentality that lead to these moves. Feel free to plead your case, champion your victories, or lob vituperations in my general direction in the comments below.

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Bright Side of the Sun Daily Roundup newsletter!

A daily roundup of Phoenix Suns news from Bright Side of the Sun