clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Would Carmelo Anthony Make The Phoenix Suns a Contender?

New, comments

Taking a look at how signing Carmelo Anthony this summer would impact the Suns roster.

Russ Isabella-USA TODAY Sports

The Phoenix Suns have reached a delicate point where they're trying to figure out how to get from being a borderline top 10 team to a legitimate NBA Championship contender.

It will take precision from both general manager Ryan McDonough and head coach Jeff Hornacek for Phoenix to take this difficult next step.

According to when Eric Bledsoe was on the court this season the Suns, played to an offensive rating of 107.4 (points per 100 possessions) and a defensive rating of 103.2.  That would have been good for the 13th best offense and 5th best defense in the NBA.   Without Bledsoe the offense improved, but the defense dropped dramatically. Phoenix profiled closer to a championship team when the Kentucky product was playing, but he missed 39 games.

When looking at what the Suns want to do this offseason there are tons of variables to work through.

Bledsoe and P.J. Tucker are restricted free agents, while Channing Frye can opt out of his contract.

Phoenix currently has a little over $25 million in 100% guaranteed money on the books for 2014-2015.  Frye's decision along with the pending cap holds of Bledsoe and Tucker will change the amount they have available to spend on potential free agents.  Phoenix also has four 2014 draft picks, which may cause a fluctuation depending on which of the picks wind up on the roster, stashed away in Europe or traded.

The Suns will have flexibility; it's more a question of how much.

Bringing back Bledsoe is a must, which will probably cost anywhere from $12 million to $15 million per season.

You also want to keep P.J. Tucker.  His skill set compliments elite, high usage talent seamlessly. Tucker doesn't need the ball in his hands, shoots corner threes at a high percentage and has the ability to guard one through four depending on matchups.

If your top two targets this summer are Carmelo Anthony and Kevin Love (and they should be if you set aside the prospect of LeBron James or Chris Bosh becoming UFAs), it makes Frye expendable.  Both Melo and Love need to be spend the majority of their minutes at the four position and to get the most out of either player you want a defensive minded rim protector next to them.

Frye alongside Melo/Love at center would be deadly offensively, but if your sinking that much money into one of those two prospective stars then redirecting the money that would be paid to Frye is a reasonable idea.

The Suns could try to clear enough cap space to sign Melo outright with available cap space or work out a sign and trade with the Knicks.

At this point Love would have to be acquired through a trade with the Timberwolves.  This makes figuring out how to build the roster a more challenging process.

For the Anthony scenario we can keep it a little bit simpler, thus making it easier to determine if investing in him as your third major piece with Bledsoe and Goran Dragic makes sense.

Looking at the payroll:

According to the Suns have $25,197,873 invested in Dragic, Beasley (not on team amnesty money), Gerald Green, Alex Len, Markieff Morris, Marcus Morris, Miles Plumlee and Archie Goodwin.

Assuming Frye opts out to capitalize on his value from this past season to get a himself a three-year contract instead of being an expiring contract. --  he's off the books.

If Phoenix brings back Bledsoe for $13 million and Tucker for $5 million that puts the Suns at $43,197,874 in player salaries with a projected NBA salary cap of $63,200,000.

Using the 2013 Draft slot values of the Suns draft picks - and assuming they keep the 14th and 18th pick plus stash the 27th in Europe -- that adds on another $3,424,080.

This brings us to a total of $46,621,954 with 11 roster spots filled, giving Phoenix around $16 million to throw at Anthony in the first year of the contract.

It also needs to be acknowledged that while this is a short term look, the long term reality is that after this season Goran Dragic can become an unrestricted free agent, Gerald Green is a UFA and the Morris brothers will both be restricted free agents.

Why Melo Makes Sense:

The Suns goal is to get a player who can push them into a top 10 offense and keep them there defensively.  When Bledsoe is healthy Phoenix is already in the top 10 on D, while adding Melo pushes them into the top third of the league offensively and won't inversely hurt them large amounts on the other end of the court if the former Knicks star is surrounded by the right players.

He's by no means an elite or even good defender, but with the right complimentary pieces, playing the right position and in a strong scheme, Melo can be part of a high level defense.

It wasn't by much or even an impressive number, but Anthony's 2013-2014 block rate reached a career high and his steal rate matched a career high in 2013-2014.  On top of that, he's an excellent defensive rebounder for his size which helps make the smaller lineups with him at power forward work.

If you can limit the amount Anthony has to chase players around on the perimeter --where he doesn't enjoy fighting through screens, can be inattentive off the ball and with rotations -- you can limit the amount of damage he does to your defensive fluidity

Right or wrong, Anthony will also take to the challenge of one on one matchups he deems worthy.  His help sliding over as the last level defending the pick and roll has improved, but still isn't something you put in a defensive teaching tutorial.

From my own experience of watching nearly every game of his since joining the Knicks, he also benefits from refs giving him a ton of leeway with his wild swats at the ball -- the full arm swing block or when instead of getting in good defensive position between the man and the basket he stands to the side to takes a swipe at the ball.

Having Melo surrounded by a defensive-minded center (getting to this position later), Tucker, Dragic and Bledsoe would be enough to keep the Suns in the top 10 of DRtg along with accentuating his offensive strengths.

What Melo Brings on Offense:

In 10 seasons in the NBA, seven full with the Nuggets and three with the Knicks, Melo's teams were on average ranked 10th offensively for the entire period and in half of the individual seasons have placed top 10.

These past two seasons with the New York, Anthony has gone from being a great offensive player to an elite offensive player (I don't even really know what that means, but Anthony has improved).

If his body holds up, specifically his shoulders, he can continue to show late career growth with a superior supporting cast.

What makes Melo's improvement more impressive is he's become more efficient with the amount of possessions he finishes going up (USG%) and a decreasing free throw rate.

His turnover percentage has been below 10% the last two seasons (there are only 36 times a player has compiled a USG rate over 30 and a TO% under 10) and his true shooting percentage has been right about 56%.

This chart appropriately puts Anthony's previous two offensive campaigns in perspective:


The jump in efficiency come from an increase in three points attempts.  Not only is Melo shooting more threes, he's hitting them at a higher percentage.   Anthony is shooting 5.5 threes per 36 minutes the past two seasons at a 39% clip and broke 40% (.402) for the first time in 13-14.  His career attempts per 36 is 3.1 and shooting percentage comes in at .345.

Anthony's deadly volume shooting off the catch has been a boon to his game.  He averaged 6.8 catch and shoots point per game according SportVU, tied for eighth best in the NBA, and only .1 less than Frye (a player who's primary offensive contribution is off catch and shoot situations).   Melo connects 43.8% of the time on catch and shoot threes, tied for 12th best in the league.  Most of these attempts are also coming above the break.

You're never going to get Olympic Melo on a consistent basis throughout a season, but the more attempts he gets like this the better.

That level of production is completely unrealistic, but the basic idea of putting him in position to make quick, decisive decisions with leverage instead of working hard on an even playing field increases his probability for a positive outcome.

It's important to remember that Anthony was able to enjoy the high level of success he's had recently with a lack of other creators on the Knicks roster.  His ability to play without the ball in his hands was largely dependent on how Ray Felton was playing.

According to SportVU this past season Melo had the ball in his hands for 3.6 minutes per game and Felton was at 5.4 MPG.

For context, Suns guard Goran Dragic had the ball in his hands 6.3 MPG and Bledsoe was in control for 5.8 MPG.   They both present significantly greater threats than Felton and would open up the court Melo.

Certainly there does need to be a balance, as you don't want to completely take the ball out of his hands.  Bledsoe and Dragic both didn't make it through the season injury free with the amount of offensive weight they had to carry.  Dragic's left ankle was a mess by the end of the year and Bledsoe's knee is a significant concern.  All three can be used to lighten the offensive load off each other.

Melo's ability to give half court sets some diversity is a huge plus if used in the correct fashion.

Anthony can have sets run through him at both elbows, the wing or from up top running pick and roll.  With trustworthy teammates surrounding him, Anthony can attack a defender one on one or find the open man with the defense shifted his way.  This can lead to open looks, especially at the three-point line, as the opposition scrambles to rotate.  Melo being more consistent passing the ball when the defense shifts his way instead of taking contested pull jumpers is something you hope the Suns coaching staff could maximize.

Despite how slow the Knicks played the past two seasons I wouldn't worry about Anthony's ability to fit in an uptempo offense.  While he was in Denver they never finished lower than 6th in pace.

Melo's flaws offensively don't shine through in statistics.  He can still fall into old habits by holding onto the ball too long, which hurts the flow of the offense.

In addition, his sense of time and situation are questionable (end of quarter and shot clock time management have been a major issue).  You want strong-minded players not afraid to look the other way as he sticks his hand out for the ball.

Set At Center?

As mentioned earlier a necessary piece next to Anthony is a center with the ability to anchor the defense by protecting the rim.

Miles Plumlee looked like an excellent complimentary piece in his first year getting real rotation minutes.  There's still room for growth and improvement in his game, but in trying to construct a higher level roster the preference would be to shift him to being a first big man off the bench.

Alex Len might be the guy to compliment a player like Melo, and I'm much higher on him than most.  The realistic progression in Len's second year is as a consistent rotation player for 15 to 20 minutes a night.  If you get anything higher that's great, but he's only going to be 21 years old going into next season.  Expecting him to play 30 minutes a night would be asking a lot.   According to there's only nine players over seven feet between the ages of 18-22 who averaged 30 minutes a game or more in their second NBA season since 1946-1947. Lowering the time to 25 MPG expands the list to 13.

If the Suns bring Melo into the fold they're saying we're ready to compete now.   Anthony will be 30 by the time next season starts and his contract will run through age 33.  I don't think the Len timeline in his development matches up with the potential two-year Carmelo window, more if you're lucky enough to get more than two years of Melo playing at his peak performance.

It doesn't mean Len is out of your big picture plans, but a need to be conscious of where he is as a player.

Finding a way to upgrade the center position in addition to signing Melo would probably be needed to give yourself an opportunity to win a seven game series against teams like the Spurs and Thunder.