clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Rookie of the Year results show how winning games and developing players don't mesh

New, comments

The top three rookies in the Rookie of the year voting this season played for some of the worst teams in the NBA, while five of the 14 lottery picks languished on the bench for winning teams.

Howard Smith-USA TODAY Sports

The NBA announced on Monday that Michael Carter-Williams won the Kia Rookie of the Year Award for the 2013-14 season.

Carter-Williams averaged 16.7 points, 6.3 assists and 6.2 rebounds, joining Oscar Robertson (1960-61) and [the Phoenix Suns'] Alvan Adams (1975-76) as the only players since 1950-51 to pace all rookies in those three categories. He also joined Robertson and Magic Johnson as the only rookies in NBA history to average at least 16.0 points, 6.0 rebounds and 6.0 assists. Carter-Williams also led all rookies in steals (1.86 spg, sixth in NBA).

Coming in second was #2 overall pick Victor Oladipo, and third was #9 overall pick Trey Burke. All three players were primary ball handlers on some of the worst teams in the NBA.

These three players fit within the normal NBA profile - lottery picks are most likely to play big minutes because their teams are rebuilding. Later picks don't play as much as rookies because their team is trying to win games.

The two Phoenix Suns draft picks, #5 overall Alex Len and #29 overall Archie Goodwin, barely played this year for one of the best teams in the NBA.

There are exceptions, but by and large winning teams have no room in their rotation for a rookie. I'm not talking about 10-15 minutes a game here. I'm not even necessarily talking about MCW, Burke and Oladipo contributions, who played 30+ minutes a night.

Over 210 draft picks in the last four seasons, only EIGHT draft picks have played 20+ minutes per game for a winning team. That's a 3.5% chance for a rookie to play 20+ minutes for a winner.

Here is the exhaustive list of draft picks (any spot 1-60) who got 20+ minutes per game on winning or playoff team in last 4 seasons

  • Evan Turner (Philadelphia, #2, 2010)*
  • Paul George (Indiana, #10, 2010)*
  • Landry Fields (New York Knicks, second round, 2010)
  • Kawhi Leonard (San Antonio Spurs, #15, 2011)
  • Iman Shumpert (New York Knicks, #17, 2011)
  • Kenneth Faried (Denver Nuggets, #21, 2011)
  • Chandler Parsons (Houston Rockets, #38, 2011)
  • Harrison Barnes (Golden State Warriors, #7, 2012)
*Some players are included because they made the playoffs, despite not having a winning record.

If you're counting, that's three players from the 2010 Draftfour players from the 2011 Draft (lockout year), one player from the 2012 Draft and none from last year. You could say that 2011 stands out as a good draft, but you could also say that those guys only got minutes because the free agent period lasted just 5 seconds or so after the new CBA was signed.

But that's it. Eight guys in four years. Eight of 210 draft picks.

Damian Lillard is not mentioned because the 2012-13 Blazers finished with just 34 wins on the season after a hot start. Mason Plumlee is not mentioned because he still didn't get to 20+ minutes on the Nets, even though the center position was decimated with Lopez and Garnett injures all season. Pablo Prigioni is not mentioned because he was 35 years old at the time he was a rookie. Gary Neal is not mentioned because he was in his fourth professional season when he signed with the Spurs.

On the flipside, there have not been many lottery picks in the past four years who even played on winning teams. Generally, lottery teams are losing teams.

Here is the list of recent lottery picks (taken 1-14) who struggled to get rotation time because they were on a winning team in their rookie season:
  • Patrick Patterson (Houston Rockets, #14, 2010)
  • Jeremy Lamb (Oklahoma City Thunder, #12, 2012)
  • Otto Porter (Washington Wizards, #3, 2013)
  • Cody Zeller (Charlotte Bobcats, #4, 2013)
  • Alex Len (Phoenix Suns, #5, 2013)
  • C.J. McCollum (Portland Trail Blazers, #10, 2013)
  • Steven Adams (Oklahoma City Thunder, #12, 2013)

This list is quite telling as well. Only 10 lottery-picking teams in the past four seasons, since 2010, have either made the playoffs or finished with a winning record in that same year. Three of those 10 played their lottery pick 20+ minutes per game that year. Seven did not.

Five of those 10 winning/playoff teams who had lotto picks occurred in 2013-14 season alone.

Where am I going with all of this?

I guess when I saw the Rookie of the Year list yesterday, I thought to myself that Suns rookies Alex Len and Archie Goodwin never had a chance.

I gave Len a "grade" on the season of D-, which was meant to simply say he didn't have a good year. Even Alex would have to agree. But if you factor in how little a chance he got, maybe he deserved a bit more consideration.

The only other team in recent memory to win 48+ games and have a lotto pick even on their roster was the Oklahoma City Thunder thanks to trades that netted the #12 pick twice in the past four years while they gobbled up wins.

Sure the 2013 Draft was a downer. Not many stars to be had. Only eight players out of 60 even cracked the 20 mpg mark this season.

But remember that complicating the matter was the number of winning basketball teams who just couldn't give the time to their raw rookies while they tried to make the playoffs.

Once the Suns started winning, Len and Goodwin didn't have a chance to shine. So cut the rookies some slack, especially Alex Len, and let them grow at a pace that contributes to winning at the same time they are developing.